Steam competitor review report: a sample

“One of the ways it does this is through its tropical setting, which includes exploring coral reefs and saving them from pollution”

“The town feels alive, more than cyberpunk ever did. People have schedules, they have jobs, they have lives.”

“Coral Island keeps introducing new mechanics, progression systems, and things to work towards.”

“Farming, diving, restoring coral reefs, mining, decorating, befriending villagers, and uncovering the island's deeper mysteries all blend together naturally”

“There's more variety in this game than most others in the genre, and that's in every category: plants, enemies, museum finds, townsfolk”

“The villagers are pretty well written with people coming from all different walks of life, actually being diverse, and being pretty inclusive.”

“The locals all have their own personalities and backstories that make getting to know each character an interesting endeavor”

“Plenty of romanceable characters and as gameplay progresses, it becomes even more elaborate”

“Each NPC feels authentically written, with dialogue that rings true and relationships that develop through meaningful interactions”

“The art style is vibrant and full of personality, and the island itself feels alive”

“Изумительная графика, приятная музыка”

English: “Amazing graphics, pleasant music”

“has THE CUTEST animations and the HOTTEST character art”

“EXCELLENT character artwork for all characters! And townies change outfits (sometimes even hairstyles) with the seasons”

“arte toda estilizada com personagens parecendo de desenhos da Disney, o que achei bem bonito”

English: “fully stylized art with characters looking like Disney drawings, which I found very beautiful”

“the underwater exploration and the fact that there are so many fully fleshed out diverse characters”

“海洋汚染がテーマにあり、シナリオ進行によって水辺が徐々に綺麗になっていくのを見るのは達成感がある”

English: “Ocean pollution is a theme, and seeing the waterside gradually become cleaner as the scenario progresses gives a sense of accomplishment”

“the tropical theme really spoke to me and I love the extra emphasis this game has on the ocean & environmental conservation”

“Coral island has added alot of features (underwater farming, cultural (indonesian) elements)”

“I absolutely L❤VE exloring the ocean and meeting all the mermaids”

“its everything Stardew but expanded on. There's more quests, more NPC's more crops, more animals, more cutscenes, more to do in general.”

“They upgraded every concept of the game. Including (and not limited to) amazing events with minigames and pamphlets, SO many more NPCs”

“Way more townies than Stardew, also way more romance options”

“tem muitas coisas diferente de stardew valley”

English: “has many things different from stardew valley”

“this game rivals even a giant like StardewValley”

“I really enjoy that I can just take my time with the game or optimize things depending on what I feel like.”

“Exelente juego para bajar el estrés”

English: “Excellent game for stress relief”

“Coral Island não te pressiona a ficar rico logo no início”

English: “Coral Island doesn't pressure you to get rich right at the beginning”

“este virou meu segundo jogo conforto”

English: “this became my second comfort game”

“Sıcacık atmosferi, huzurlu müzikleri ve tatlı karakterleriyle içinizi ısıtan bir deneyim”

English: “A warm atmosphere, peaceful music and sweet characters that warm your heart”

“There has been so much added and improved”

“it's only gotten better since the early release with frequent, exciting updates”

“There have been some big updates. It is a great time to start playing.”

“continually bring free updates that greatly improve the feel of the game”

“have fixed a ton of problems and bugs the game had at the start”

“think of any quality of life update you've wanted in Stardew and its there”

“crafting can be done from anywhere with materials in your chests”

“As mecânicas e ferramentas são super bem feitas, tudo flui naturalmente”

English: “The mechanics and tools are super well-made, everything flows naturally”

“One of the cleanest and most well-designed user interfaces I've ever seen”

“The game has a lot of quality of life features which makes the game play so well”

“Le jeu vaut son prix avec autant de quêtes et quêtes secondaires”

English: “The game is worth its price with so many quests and side quests”

“Time and money well spent”

“It's worth the price!”

“The story-line is fun and always keeps you looking forward to playing another day”

“Histoire très remplie et très longue, bons graphismes”

English: “Very full and very long story, good graphics”

“a very polished game with a metric ton of content, works great on the Steam Deck”

“Runs well, without lagging, crashing, or bugging.”

“the fact Coral Island runs *normally* is incredibly impressive”

“É muito bom poder jogar com amigos”

English: “It's very good to be able to play with friends”

“on est à fond sur notre game en multi”

English: “We're going hard on our multiplayer game”

“The story is great, character's stories are entertaining, and something about farming/collecting trash in the ocean is so peaceful”

“incredibly fun, addicting, cute”

“bugs and issues, many dating back to early release that the developers just seem completely oblivious or indifferent to”

“they released an update that destroyed 600 hours of progress because saves don't work from one update to the next.”

“Такое количество багов и гличей я помню только в седьмых героях на релизе”

English: “I remember such a quantity of bugs and glitches only in Heroes 7 on release”

“there are still many bugs riddled throughout that have been known about for years”

“not even 10 hours into the game I discovered a lot of bugs already”

“Mining is an unrewarding chore; ore spawn rates are abysmal, meaning you can break a hundred rocks and maybe get five actual ores”

“Its been FULLY RELEASED, 1.0, for almost 3 years. WITHOUT full content”

“Это просто комнаты с однообразными врагами, которые даже не нападают на тебя, пока ты не подойдешь вплотную”

English: “It's just rooms with uniform enemies that don't even attack you until you get close”

“Player为什么不结婚不生子就不能扩建住宅？？？不仅催婚还催生？”

English: “Why can't players expand housing without marriage and children? Not only pushing marriage but also pushing having children?”

“it still feels incomplete in many aspects, which prevents me from recommending it in its current state”

“the amount it easily crashes is absolutely insane. Editing the farm, the house, even traveling can cause this game to crash.”

“The most frustrating crashes of my entire life”

“The game crashes far too often, and every time it does, I lose a whole day of progress.”

“crashes remain one of the biggest issues I've experienced”

“刚解锁海洋种地时捡了一堆贝壳 准备查查wiki哪些有用 结果直接崩了”

English: “just unlocked ocean farming, collected a bunch of shells to check wiki, crashed directly”

“game pacing is weird and too quickly leaves you in a place where all you have left is endless tedium of the same farming loop”

“the Diving component is slow and tedious”

“the grind is a SLOG. you either love this title or you drop it in the mid-game.”

“巨肝，海底清垃圾的玩法是人能想出来的”

English: “Very grindy, ocean garbage cleanup gameplay is something humans could think of?”

“terribly grindy and awfully demanding of your time and effort”

“The characters are shallow and largely one-dimensional.”

“Персонажи настолько пустые, что с ними никак неинтересно взаимодействовать”

English: “Characters are so empty that it is impossible to interact with them in any interesting way”

“可攻略NPC个人故事充斥着家庭矛盾，包括不限于父子，继母女，姐弟，姐妹，离婚夫妻等等”

English: “Romanceable NPC personal stories are filled with family conflicts, including father-son, stepmother-daughter, siblings, divorced couples, etc.”

“романтическая линия нулевая. Персонажи не проявляют к тебе интереса”

English: “the romantic storyline is zero. Characters show no interest in you”

“getting to know the villagers of Coral Island feels strangely empty. The heart events often feel more like I'm an awkward observer”

“Multiplayer is very buggy: hardlocks, constant crashes and just generally sloppy implementation.”

“开加速器联机还会掉线，联机玩家极其不推荐”

English: “even with accelerator multiplayer still disconnects, extremely not recommended for multiplayer players”

“after 1.3 update co op is a disaster”

“the second player keeps running into insane bugs where they either fall through the floor, the game crashes, there are black screens”

“Co-op game keeps "losing connection"”

“This should not be Verified on Steam Deck. It stutters badly regardless of settings”

“poorly optomised for cross platform still game breaking bugs”

“the game is so laggy that it's completely unplayable, no matter what settings you use”

“이게임을 하면 한번씩 그래픽 카드가 힘든 소리를 내면서 컴퓨터가 다운이 되고있네요”

English: “When playing this game my graphics card makes struggling sounds and the computer keeps crashing”

“This game has a terrible memory leak problem. Devs should have fixed this by now”

“copies too much from Stardew Valley (crop quality, museum, offerings and so on)”

“This game is Stardew Valley with a cocomelon skin and worse dialogue.”

“this is just such a Stardew Valley copy it's insane”

“feels like they just copy and pasted stardew valley's opening. and i mean almost exactly”

“Coral Island von vorne bis hinten ein kompletter Stardew-Klon ist”

English: “Coral Island is a complete Stardew clone from start to finish”

“Even the fishing mechanic feels dumb and clunky”

“The controls feel a bit clunky, the running animation looks faster than you actually move”

“EVERYTHING is so ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ slow. Walking speed, dialog text, cutscenes, tool animations.”

“Controls don't feel very fluid or satisfying”

“The mines are boring and the clunky controls make it frustrating at times”

“периодически выкатываете обновления, переводите игру на разные экзотические языки и при этом старательно игнорируете русский”

English: “you periodically roll out updates, translate the game into various exotic languages while carefully ignoring Russian”

“日常会話が翻訳されておらず全て英語です。”

English: “Daily conversations are not translated and are all in English.”

“La traduction est épouvantable.”

English: “The translation is appalling.”

“汉化非常差，机翻感很强，经常前言不搭后语，做任务的时候不知道NPC要的到底是什么”

English: “Localization is very poor, feels heavily machine translated, often incoherent, unclear what NPC wants when doing quests”

“번역 안된 부분들이 너무 많음 일상 대화에서도 가끔 영어나오고 NPC 개인 스토리에도 영어나오면”

English: “Too many untranslated parts, sometimes English appears in everyday dialogue and in NPC individual stories”

“hated the lack of music”

“LOUD ASS INTRO”

“music being too quiet, non-memorable, and sometimes non-existent”

“every time I tried to play it- the audio has EXTREMELY bad tearing”

“bare feet farmer boot and everything in between make the same footsteps sound”

“Coral Island is almost 3x the price of Stardew Valley”

“I would say this is a 20$ game”

“Um jogo com tantos pequenos problemas custar quase quatro vezes o valor de Stardew Valley é difícil de justificar”

“比如银矿石15一个，银锭75一个，一个银锭用5银矿加一个煤炭燃烧制作，算下来还亏了个煤炭的钱”

English: “For example, silver ore is 15 each, silver ingot is 75, but one ingot needs 5 silver ore plus coal, so you lose money on coal”

“sells for almost four times the price”

“combat is pointless because the monsters are laughable and practically sleep through encounters”

“it got repetitive and not so challenging”

“the festival mini games are all impossible”

“the character animations also feel very janky”

“I find both the main char as well as NPCs incredibly unattractive”

“不推荐人物画风太丑了”

English: “Not recommended, character art style is too ugly”

“Pełne 3D może i jest plusem na piewszy rzut oka... Ale dla mnie daje za bardzo wrażenie stylu graficznego gry mobilnej”

English: “Full 3D might be a plus at first glance, but for me it gives too much of a mobile game graphical style feeling”

“the developers have decided to not allow players to manually save”

“A forced online game that you can only save once a day. It's inherently incompatible”

“There are so many worlds, quests, mysteries, and even romance options”

“the way where there is always something to work towards without feeling overwhelming”

“This game has a beautiful world to explore”

“The FANTASY aspect had me intrigued. It takes everything I enjoy about the genre and adds enough unique features to make it stand out”

“가구나 코디템등 꾸미는 요소가 엄청 다양하고 자유로움”

English: “decorating elements like furniture and coordination items are extremely diverse and free”

“게임 규모가 훨씬 크고, 플레이해 보니 정말 잘 만든 게임이라는 게 느껴졌어요”

English: “The game scale is much larger, and playing it felt like it was really well-made”

“supera Stardew Valley”

English: “surpasses Stardew Valley”

“If you liked Stardew Valley, but wanted a more fantasy inclined farming sim, this is the game for you”

“there's like 4 different towns to explore, better combat”

“It has more storyline and questing, so you dont feel like you're just doing the same thing over and over”

“É muito bonito, confortável e gostoso de jogar.”

English: “It is very beautiful, comfortable and nice to play.”

“I played this game casually, love it after that”

“gaming is supposed to be about relaxing and having fun and this game is both of those things”

“It is so relaxing while also being very engaging and fun”

“very fun farm sim with magic elements”

“one of the most beautifully drawn and decorated worlds”

“The art feels polished and beautiful, every area of the game looks unique due to it.”

“This is basically Stardew Valley on fantasy crack with slightly better pixel art.”

“I love the Art they put into the game.”

“Excellent pixel art, great scripting, every character looks and acts different.”

“游戏好玩，有傻瓜模式对战斗手残很友好”

English: “Game is fun, has easy mode that is very friendly to combat disabled players”

“MUCH faster movement (you get a 0 cooldown air dash spell at level 1)”

“전투적인 요소가 좀 더 다채로워”

English: “combat elements are more diverse”

“Stardew with a massive world and better combat.”

“цікава система бойовки, на відміну від Стард'ю. Додається система магії”

English: “interesting combat system, unlike Stardew. Magic system is added”

“The characters are pretty interesting and it easily pulled us into the story”

“You can do so many more things with a very rich and intresting story.”

“доволі рідкість в геймплеї пробачень, майже всі персонажі ментально здорові, та не поводять себе як мразі”

English: “quite rare in gameplay, almost all characters are mentally healthy and don't act like jerks”

“A deep story rich farming sim with a romance tilt.”

“иинтересный сюжет”

English: “interesting plot”

“This game is so much fun with friends or solo!”

“Bonus points for the amazing co op feature that allows you to play with up to 8 friends”

“Das Co-Op System funktioniert einwandfrei”

English: “The co-op system works flawlessly”

“Great coop questing. Excellent with a friend.”

“같이하는사람이랑 스토리 동시에 미는게아니라 각자해도되는거라 스토리독촉없어서 좋았음”

English: “You don't have to progress the story together, you can do it separately so no story rushing pressure”

“Tools don't break, and your character can mine and work on the farm without worrying about getting tired”

“the lack of a restrictive stamina system”

“самый жир тут нет этой дебильной полоски энергии”

English: “the best part is there's no stupid energy bar”

“NO ENERGY bar”

“Quests assist with game progression nicely. I like not having to burn up energy”

“You can change how quick your day goes in-game, without having to save and restart”

“Fishing is less distressing than SDV”

“A MAP THAT SHOWS YOU MOST IMPORTANT PLACES BY DEFAULT, CONSTANTLY UPDATES WITH IMPORTANT CHARACTERS LOCATIONS”

“within ur quest tab it'll tell you where youd most likely need to go/who u need to talk to”

“the characters are well designed and pleasant to look at”

“Der Fantasy-Aspekt war für mich mal was ganz neues im Zusammenhang mit einem Farming-Game.”

English: “The fantasy aspect was something completely new for me in connection with a farming game.”

“Character creation is the most immersive one in any farming sim I have played”

“Der Charakter-Editor ist richtig toll”

English: “The character editor is really great”

“você poder escolher raça e muita customização”

“хорошо затягивает”

English: “very engaging”

“A game you can get lost in for hours”

“super addicting to play”

“The farming and dating aspects are super cozy.”

“You can gain hearts with characters so much faster than other farming games”

“the translations themselves are buggy and oftentimes gibberish”

“都他妈的几年了，机翻问题竟然还没解决”

English: “After so many damn years, machine translation issues still aren't fixed”

“The German translation often doesn't make any sense”

“游戏名Sun haven能在多处翻译成"桑黑文"”

English: “the game name Sun Haven can be translated to 'sang hei wen' in multiple places”

“한글 번역 있다고 구라 치고 팔지 말고 번역 좀 똑바로 해라”

English: “don't lie about having Korean translation and sell it, fix the translation properly”

“Releases DLC's left and right worse than EA”

“releasing a hundred stupid paid cosmetic DLCs while ignoring the numerous bugs”

“The DLC's are expensive”

“Instead they'd rather put out $140 of DLC instead of fixing their game after 5 years”

“push of more content over polishing what's there”

“it's a case of too many ideas in one pot, which leads to inconsistencies, weird tone, and generally a bit of a mess”

“many of them either have no purpose, get devalued by other mechanics, or feel unfinished”

“the current experience feels disjointed”

“it's kind of an unfinished game”

“Sun Haven tries to do so much and it stretches itself too thin.”

“3-4 farms you can manage alone, but damn near impossible to do without playing in multiplayer mode”

“Most bonuses from the skill tree are so small they might as well not be there”

“95 часов я больше провела копаясь в шахте ради того что бы просто прокачать свои инструменты”

English: “95 hours I spent mostly digging in the mine just to level up my tools”

“The story and characters are lacking depth. The dialogues don't feel genuine. To improve the relationship you need to butter them up.”

“不卡体力槽就卡时间是吧”

English: “If it doesn't lock your stamina bar, it locks your time”

“all the unaddressed bugs and issues”

“a looooooooot of bugs, which never got adressed”

“I find I am unable to grow certain crops (yes, they are in season).”

“viele Mechaniken nicht wirklich funktionierten, nicht ineinander griffen oder schlichtweg einfach nicht existierten”

English: “many mechanics didn't really work, didn't fit together or simply didn't exist”

“this game feels raw, unpolished, and full of bugs”

“lack of accountability from the devs about bugs and quality”

“the base game keeps breaking every time they do an update”

“Materialien/Feldfrüchte/etc weiter zu verarbeiten bringt fast gar nichts und generell ist das ganze Währungssystem völlig im Eimer.”

English: “Processing materials/crops/etc. brings almost nothing and the entire currency system is completely broken.”

“sofre com alguns bugs chatos”

English: “suffers from some annoying bugs”

“импрувмент не был замечен, только баги и кривой ui (серьезно, за три года с выхода игры ничего толком не пофиксить??)”

English: “no improvement noticed, only bugs and broken ui (seriously, for three years since release nothing is really fixed??)”

“coop is working so damn badly, its unbelievable”

“i have DLC using it on multiplayer, my friend cant use the MOUNTS, all of the MOUNTS is unuseable to him”

“story heavily single player? no body in town acknowledges that there are multiple players. You spawn on top of each other in the cutscenes”

“not all bosses are able to be fought together, yet you're both in the same arena fighting the boss in different instances”

“developers think its ok to have cosmetic skins without fixing the multiplayer problems”

“theres a funny bug where if you passed out at night, all of the item in the shipment will disappear!”

“When closing the game, if the host saves and exits before all players, every other player will have their character corrupted”

“При сносе дома теряются все предметы внутри, в том числе лимитированные.”

English: “When demolishing a house all items inside are lost, including limited items”

“THE AUTOSAVE IS SOO ANOYING”

“the major monthly seasonal event are out of sink.....meaning your friend or friends wont be abled to attend them”

“mechanical control annoyances and bugs that have exist since early EA and they still exist”

“Controls are really bad - and controls make or break a game for me.”

“would have been awesome if it would not have kept dropping my controller every load of the game”

“I love to play with my controller but this game only partial support on it”

“the FPS sometimes randomly drops to 25 or 5”

“10% of my f-ing playtime is just waiting the first load of the farm”

“矿洞每一层都要坐大概七八秒的重复动画”

English: “Mine shafts have to watch approximately 7-8 seconds of repeated animation on every floor”

“вырвиглазная графика, играть долго в это невозможно, слишком много мелькающих окон”

English: “Eye-straining graphics, impossible to play for long, too many flickering windows”

“RECORDÉ EL DESASTRE desorganizado que es. Tengo que ir viendo cosa por cosa dónde va cada”

English: “I REMEMBERED THE MESS it is. I have to go thing by thing to see where each goes”

“Achei o jogo bagunçado, muita coisa de inicio, progressão estranha”

English: “I found the game disorganized, too much at the beginning, strange progression”

“스타듀밸리 파쿠리 독창적인건 잘 모르겠고”

English: “Stardew Valley copy - can't tell if there's anything original”

“Очень слабый стардью велли”

English: “very weak Stardew Valley”

“The mini games and mechanics are refreshing”

“pure Wohlfühl-Atmosphäre”

English: “pure comfort atmosphere”

“é um dos jogos mais relaxantes que eu já joguei, os personagens são muito fofos”

English: “It's one of the most relaxing games I've ever played, the characters are very cute”

“you can take it at your own pace”

“there is not time limit and you can play without rushing”

“A great balance of farming, exploring, and social interactions with the cast of NPCs”

“you can't finish the game in a day (there is SO MUCH content and SO MANY items”

“the amount of content this game contains without having to buy DLC surprised me again and again”

“Lots of plant and animal variety.”

“They keep the gameplay so interesting with introductions of new ideas and developments”

“This might be the only farming sim I've ever played that has a system for domesticating crops over time!”

“The gimmick of being set in the stone age is very well thought out and permeates every inch of the game”

“El concepto es totalmente original, se aleja de lo tipico sin tampoco perder la esencia”

English: “the concept is completely original, distances itself from the typical without losing the essence”

“they deliver the usually 'normal' mechanics of this game genre in a unique way”

“does quite a few original takes to its features”

“how a few minor changes to the currency and upgrade systems made the game feel much more community-focused”

“feels like the tribe is actually trying to improve/grow without you being the only one doing anything”

“Especially growing your children from a newborn to a child that goes to school and chooses a profession is quite rich in this game”

“A real nice shift from being the only person who can save a failing town.”

“Мені подобається акцент на спілкуванні з нпс, особливо механіка ідеї, по суті це змушує тебе бути частиною спільноти”

English: “I like the emphasis on communicating with NPCs, especially the idea mechanic, essentially making you part of the community”

“游戏风格很有特色，完成度非常高”

English: “The game style is very distinctive, completion is extremely high”

“Adorable art style”

“Its super creative, pretty to look at”

“Each character has their own little dance animation? The in-game numbered clock appears once you discover sundials? It's incredible!”

“uma obra de arte tanto em conceito quanto em visual”

English: “a work of art both in concept and visual”

“You can pet ALL the dogs (and lion cubs, and baby mammoths, and bunnies, and wild boars, and...)”

“You can ride almost any animal you tame.”

“将野生动物和植物培养成家养动物和作物的过程也很有成就感”

English: “The process of domesticating wild animals and plants into domestic animals and crops is very rewarding”

“mechanics for farm animals (especially the fact that they're quite different !)”

“você precisa domesticar os animais ao invés de comprá-los”

English: “you need to domesticate animals instead of buying them”

“la historia que es bastante mas compleja de lo habitual en este tipo de juegos”

English: “the story is quite more complex than usual in this type of games”

“There is background lore to the world, the history of the clan, the gods/spirits, etc.”

“de a gente poder conversar com nossos filhos, acompanhar o crescimento e o desenvolvimento da personalidade deles deixou minha experiência ainda mais imersiva”

English: “being able to talk with our children, watch their growth and personality development made my experience even more immersive”

“the story line engaging”

“The overall story that unfolds ties everything together nicely”

“The devs continue to support the game with really solid updates”

“There's also a ton of QOL improvements over similar farming sims”

“vários recursos de qualidade de vida interessantes, como: inventário próprio para sementes e para as ferramentas”

English: “several interesting quality of life features, such as: separate inventory for seeds and tools”

“The way you progress upgrades and ways to make new items is really nice”

“an update that brought some much appreciated quality of life features, like seeing which animal variant you already tamed.”

“I enjoy this game more than stardew”

“I got it because my computer wouldn't load Stardew Valley, and I enjoy it so much”

“比星露谷更对我的胃口”

English: “More to my taste than Stardew Valley”

“this one does a great job at taking a fun formula and making it FEEL new”

“스듀라이크 게임 중에 손에 꼽게 잘 만들었음”

English: “Exceptionally well made among Stardew-like games”

“loved playing this with my husband. We had a great time”

“extra fun when you play it in multiplayer”

“4명이 농사, 낚시, 목축업, 광질 나눠서 하고있는데 하는일 1도 안 겹쳐서 좋음”

English: “4 people farming, fishing, livestock, mining separately and tasks don't overlap at all which is good”

“the multiplayer mode is also quite nice”

“it's great co-op”

“It's in my top 5 favorite games”

“真的很好玩，为什么这么冷门啊，我真的很喜欢”

English: “Really fun, why is it so obscure, I really like it”

“Крайне рекомендую эту игру”

English: “I highly recommend this game”

“A delightful game that had me addicted for quite a while”

“It's one of the few post-Stardew Valley games that feels like a proper evolution of the farming sim genre”

“o sistema de musica e dança existentes no jogo, que da para dizer ser o diferencial”

English: “the music and dance system in the game, which can be said to be the differentiator”

“La música es preciosa”

English: “The music is beautiful”

“it has such good music, dialogue and characters”

“The music is fantastic. The soundtrack is on my youtube playlist”

“브금이나 맵디자인도 잘 어울려서 좋았음”

English: “The music and map design fit well and were great”

“the cave puzzles themselves are VERY entertaining”

“a exploração das cavernas são intrigantes e divertidas”

English: “cave exploration is intriguing and fun”

“矿洞没有蘸豆我很喜欢，只要老实挖矿就行”

English: “I really like that the mines don't have annoying minigames, just honest mining”

“把星露谷里的矿洞战斗改成了解谜”

English: “Changed the cave combat from Stardew Valley into puzzles”

“The fishing, bug catching, and mining puzzles were different from the other games of this type”

“引导是我见过有史以来最好，游玩逻辑合理且循序渐进”

English: “The tutorial is the best I've ever seen, gameplay logic is reasonable and progressive”

“instead of grinding for metals for sprinklers you create a single pump and build a bunch of trenches”

“Smooth transitions from one area to the next”

“It's great on steam deck”

“The game is also very polished. Everything works smooth and I havent encountered a single bug.”

“the second half of it is an absolute SLOG. It stopped being fun 100 hours ago”

“everything in Roots of Pacha feels much grindier — for example, getting better tools, improving irrigation”

“Too much hand holding and linear gameplay for my liking”

“this one really has no payoff; it's bland and very grindy”

“it got too repetitive and grindy”

“the devs decided to introduce a time-traveler in the late game, and every time she comes onto the screen, my experience actively gets worse”

“It takes half the game to meet all the characters”

“Completely mundane dialogue. "Bork works too much. He should spend some time resting." Okay? I don't care?”

“the lack of a narrative framing to explain the player's presence in the tribe”

“The character writing is bland and uninspired.”

“最初に種を見つけて植えるクエストが始まるが全くヒントや誘導も無い”

English: “The initial quest to find and plant seeds starts with no hints or guidance”

“improving irrigation (which is a real pain)”

“switching tools is a huge pain. you can't quickly switch between 2 tools”

“just label your stuff male or female”

“The "Ideas" are constantly thrown at you and it's overwhelming”

“You are super slow and at the beginning you're just wasting all of your time running around”

“progression is too slow and not meaningful enough already”

“The game is quite monotonous, forcing you to run around a lot and check the same areas over and over.”

“水やりはいつまでも面倒で、そもそも畑での収益がしょぼい”

English: “Watering is always tedious, and farm profits are poor to begin with”

“１日が１５分しかない”

English: “Only 15 minutes per day”

“The game world also feels a lot emptier”

“There is no variation in day to day. I am in the middle of my second year and there really is no incentive”

“这样就会产生一个悖论，那就是如果我每天游手好闲，就不会饿”

English: “this creates a paradox where if I idle every day, I won't go hungry”

“There is no combat, which doesn't help, since even rudimentary combat helped break things up in Stardew”

“The progression system holds your hand and leaves nothing to the imagination.”

“При подключении к игроку пишется надпись ClientTimeout и вылетает на главный экран”

English: “When connecting to a player it shows ClientTimeout and crashes to main menu”

“не работает мультиплеер”

English: “multiplayer doesn't work”

“Мультиплеер не работает.”

English: “Multiplayer does not work.”

“man kann mit coop spielern nicht interagieren .. wtf”

English: “you can't interact with coop players .. wtf”

“发售一年了联机模式都不修的吗”

English: “It's been a year since release and the multiplayer mode still isn't fixed?”

“The animal husbandry takes FOREVER”

“I enjoyed the animal mechanic at first, but over time the mini game just got annoying”

“驯服动物的音乐游戏又臭又长，且毫无难度”

English: “The animal taming music game is tedious and long, with no difficulty”

“my animals are constantly getting sick and fleas, cure them next day another lot will be sick”

“The game also feels as if it is forcing you backwards sometimes, such as with the animal breeding system”

“You can't just get a bigger watering can with your resources or money, you need to wait until a villager gets the idea”

“Everything feels very artificially time gated. The game is just... boring.”

“too dialogue and mission heavy”

“세이브가 날아갔어요..! 아무 이유도 없이!”

English: “My save file disappeared..! For no reason at all!”

“저장 기록 싹 초기화되는 건 무슨 오류입니까”

“玩着游戏崩了不下几十次”

English: “the game crashes dozens of times while playing”

“It's a fine Stardew Valley clone, but it isn't and never will be a Stardew Valley replacement.”

“got this game bc i love stardew and its very similar but it's almost bad”

“A copy of Stardew Valley, even on its quests.”

“no alternative paths or choices just a simple railroaded experience”

“洞窟が遠いのに納品物を突き止めたら、一度帰って用意し、再度戻って納品するのがちょっと面倒くさい”

English: “Caves are far away, and once you identify what to deliver, you have to go back, prepare, and return to deliver, which is tedious”

“At the price point it's just not worth it”

“things are too expensive for no real reason”

“这游戏里面塞满了小游戏且无法跳过，新鲜感过去了就很烦”

English: “This game is packed with minigames that cannot be skipped, after the novelty wears off it's very annoying”

“There's no option to rebind the keys. I'm left-handed.”

“brak wersji PL,”

English: “no Polish version,”

“全成就玩家不要靠近！不要靠近！不要靠近！”

English: “achievement hunters stay away! Stay away! Stay away!”